SUPPORT OUR
SPONSORS
Crap Happens: A Grist Special Report on Sewage Sludge
-
Sludge: Farmer's Friend or Toxic Slime?
By Catherine Price
Grist Magazine, May 4, 2009
Straight to the Source
Urine, feces, menstrual blood, hair, fingernails, vomit, dead skin cells. Industrial chemicals, pharmaceuticals, soaps, shampoos, solvents, pesticides, household cleansers, hospital waste.
Sewage sludge, the viscous brown gunk left over when wastewater is treated, is more than just poop: it's an odiferous smoothie of everything we pour down the drain. There are pathogens; there are heavy metals. PCBs, dioxins, DDT, asbestos, polio, parasitic worms, radioactive material-all have been found in sludge. Despite pretreatment programs that prevent some of the most noxious stuff from entering the public sewers, sludge can include so many toxins that the Clean Water Act lists it as a "pollutant."
So it's a little surprising where it ends up: Today more than half of America's sewage sludge is spread on land as fertilizer.
Granted, this isn't a new idea. For most of human history, our crap has ended up back on land-and it wasn't until the past century, which brought flush toilets and public sewers to mainstream America, that using excrement as fertilizer started sounding at all strange. Sure, this system was driven partially by convenience, but it also made ecological sense: our urine and feces contain the same nutrients that plants need. Spreading it on land closes the nutrient loop; it avoids the need for chemical fertilizers. Eat, shit, fertilize, and eat again. For thousands of years, this arrangement worked just fine.
Or, rather, almost fine. As human populations grew and concentrated, health problems like cholera outbreaks inspired a push for flush toilets and public sewer systems. This led to huge improvements in public health, but resulted in a new problem: sewers mixed domestic sewage with industrial waste and spewed it untreated into rivers and lakes. The next step was sewage treatment plants, which separated liquids from solids, but in solving one issue they created yet another: the cleaner they made the water, the dirtier the leftover sludge. Adding to the challenge, as the population of the United States grew, so did the amount of sludge: we're currently generating more than 7 million dry tons a year and counting-and we have no intention of cutting back.
Meanwhile, as a mycelium of sewer pipes spreads underneath our cities to whisk our waste away from us, Americans became increasingly squeamish about dealing with excrement. We're now a nation of "fecaphobes," obsessed with toilet humor but unaware and uninterested in what happens to our actual crap. We don't want to think about it; we don't want to deal with it. We want to flush the toilet and forget.
Click here for the rest of this article.
Sewage sludge, the viscous brown gunk left over when wastewater is treated, is more than just poop: it's an odiferous smoothie of everything we pour down the drain. There are pathogens; there are heavy metals. PCBs, dioxins, DDT, asbestos, polio, parasitic worms, radioactive material-all have been found in sludge. Despite pretreatment programs that prevent some of the most noxious stuff from entering the public sewers, sludge can include so many toxins that the Clean Water Act lists it as a "pollutant."
So it's a little surprising where it ends up: Today more than half of America's sewage sludge is spread on land as fertilizer.
Granted, this isn't a new idea. For most of human history, our crap has ended up back on land-and it wasn't until the past century, which brought flush toilets and public sewers to mainstream America, that using excrement as fertilizer started sounding at all strange. Sure, this system was driven partially by convenience, but it also made ecological sense: our urine and feces contain the same nutrients that plants need. Spreading it on land closes the nutrient loop; it avoids the need for chemical fertilizers. Eat, shit, fertilize, and eat again. For thousands of years, this arrangement worked just fine.
Or, rather, almost fine. As human populations grew and concentrated, health problems like cholera outbreaks inspired a push for flush toilets and public sewer systems. This led to huge improvements in public health, but resulted in a new problem: sewers mixed domestic sewage with industrial waste and spewed it untreated into rivers and lakes. The next step was sewage treatment plants, which separated liquids from solids, but in solving one issue they created yet another: the cleaner they made the water, the dirtier the leftover sludge. Adding to the challenge, as the population of the United States grew, so did the amount of sludge: we're currently generating more than 7 million dry tons a year and counting-and we have no intention of cutting back.
Meanwhile, as a mycelium of sewer pipes spreads underneath our cities to whisk our waste away from us, Americans became increasingly squeamish about dealing with excrement. We're now a nation of "fecaphobes," obsessed with toilet humor but unaware and uninterested in what happens to our actual crap. We don't want to think about it; we don't want to deal with it. We want to flush the toilet and forget.
Click here for the rest of this article.






