Search OCA:
Get Local!

Find Local News, Events & Green Businesses on OCA's State Pages:

OCA News Sections

Organic Consumers Association

Raw Milk Might Have a Future in Canada but Questions Remain

For Related Articles and More Information, Please Visit OCA's Healthy Raw Milk Page and our Canada News Page.

GUELPH, Ont. -- Science-based evidence in food safety seriously compromises any argument for allowing raw milk to be freely sold to Canadians. Even a small amount of raw milk can seriously harm a child, a pregnant woman, the elderly, individuals with a compromised immune system, or anyone for that matter; just one glass will do it.

Still, it appears that support to legalize its distribution is growing in North America. In fact, Louisiana is considering loosening its laws to permit raw milk to be legally sold to consumers. In Canada, raw milk crusader Michael Schmidt, despite a recent legal setback, seems to be making some inroads, and an increasing number of people support his cause.

Some have turned this debate into one about the freedom of choice, while proponents of the status quo in Canada perceive this to be a public-health matter.

It is much more complicated than that, however.

Since 1991, regulations require that milk be pasteurized in order to be sold in Canada. The Canadian Food Inspection Agency clearly states that raw milk can harbour dangerous microorganisms that can pose serious health risks; but such a claim is vigorously disputed by raw-milk advocates. They believe our current law breaches consumers' rights to choose, and they say that freedom always comes with certain risks, even in food. Some studies suggest that pasteurization takes away some of milk's nutritional benefits, which would support the view of pro-raw milk groups.

That said, the findings of many other studies are inconclusive; thus, to draw any definitive conclusions would be premature. We do know more than we did in 1991, but much remains to be discovered by food scientists.

When it comes to raw milk, risk perceptions vary greatly between countries. In Europe, for example, consumers can buy raw milk from public vending machines, while many American states already allow for raw milk to be sold by retailers. This stands in contrast to Canada.

Dairy farmers, arguably Canadian agriculture's most powerful lobby group, perceive any change to the current legislative regime as an economic threat. Even if raw milk probably would appeal only to a marginal number of consumers, dairy farmers still consider this a potential menace, however small.

Facing the influential dairy sector are small-farm operators like Michael Schmidt who want some attention as well, and are emphasizing the virtues of local, straight-to-consumer milk distribution. They, too, warrant the trust of consumers.    

>>> Read the Full Article

For more information on this topic or related issues you can search the thousands of archived articles on the OCA website using keywords: