SUPPORT OUR
SPONSORS
Organic Justice: Helping Poor People Buy Organic Food Directly from Farmers
-
A CSA Option for the Poor
Local Harvest, January 2008
Straight to the Source
For years, people have been trying to figure out how Community Supported Agriculture (CSA) projects could be made accessible to low income people. Economically, the CSA model is built on farmers' need for capital at the beginning of the growing season. Most CSAs ask their members to pay a lump sum for the entire season, a requirement that bars low-income people from participating.
Many farmers and food activists have been bothered by this, and some have worked together on solutions. Just Food is one well-known organization that develops CSAs for people in New York's underserved neighborhoods. One way they do this is by fundraising among wealthier CSA members to offset the cost of the low-income shares. This solution creates an economically diverse CSA and ensures that the farmers receive a fair price for their products.
But is it possible for a farm to open the doors of its CSA to poor people without working through a non-profit? We recently spoke with one farmer who has found a way to do just that, Crystine Goldberg of Uprising Farm.
Goldberg and her partner Brian Campbell founded Uprising with two intentions: saving heirloom and open pollinated seeds, and getting good food to people regardless of income. After three seasons as market farmers, Goldberg and Campbell started a small CSA last year. It exclusively serves low income people, and the members pay with electronic food stamp benefits, known as EBT.
The USDA, which administers the federal food stamp program, does not allow EBT to be used for traditional CSAs. In order to make their idea work, Uprising had to re-shape its program in two important ways. First, they allowed people to pay for their CSA baskets every week or two, because a pre-payment arrangement would violate USDA rules. Second, in their USDA application to be licensed to accept EBT, they had to describe their project as a "farm stand" rather than as a CSA. Given the model they are using - members pay for the food when it is picked up - a farm stand is in fact the more accurate financial description.
Other potential snags with USDA rules (entering into contracts for food purchases, or using EBT to repay loans) were addressed in their USDA application so that they and the federal agency were clear that the "CSA" was a legitimate use of EBT.
Once their application was accepted, which Goldberg says was a fairly simple process, the farm was given a machine to swipe the CSA members' EBT cards and make the sales each week. The government then deposited the food stamp funds directly into the farm's bank account, thus making the money handling efficient and eliminating dreaded paperwork.
Finding CSA members was also painless. The farmers hung posters and brochures around town and told friends who helped spread the word. Goldberg says that acquiring shareholders was easy because so many people are interested in CSA. Most of the members are signing up again for this year's program, and the farm is already getting calls and email from other people who would like to join.
Throughout several interviews, Goldberg had one message for farmers who might consider starting a similar CSA-type program. The message is, "It's really very simple!" The only unexpected issue the couple encountered last year was the lag time between filing their application with the USDA, getting it approved, and getting set up with their EBT machine. Goldberg encourages other farmers to start the process at least two months before the beginning of the CSA. She and Campbell had an utterly positive experience with their all-EBT modified CSA. "It's so necessary and so appreciated" by the shareholders, Goldberg said. "The hardest part was figuring out who to call to get the application." We'll save you that step - here it is. Goldberg says she would be happy to talk with farmers who are considering starting this type of project, with their entire CSA, or a dedicated portion of it.
Many farmers and food activists have been bothered by this, and some have worked together on solutions. Just Food is one well-known organization that develops CSAs for people in New York's underserved neighborhoods. One way they do this is by fundraising among wealthier CSA members to offset the cost of the low-income shares. This solution creates an economically diverse CSA and ensures that the farmers receive a fair price for their products.
But is it possible for a farm to open the doors of its CSA to poor people without working through a non-profit? We recently spoke with one farmer who has found a way to do just that, Crystine Goldberg of Uprising Farm.
Goldberg and her partner Brian Campbell founded Uprising with two intentions: saving heirloom and open pollinated seeds, and getting good food to people regardless of income. After three seasons as market farmers, Goldberg and Campbell started a small CSA last year. It exclusively serves low income people, and the members pay with electronic food stamp benefits, known as EBT.
The USDA, which administers the federal food stamp program, does not allow EBT to be used for traditional CSAs. In order to make their idea work, Uprising had to re-shape its program in two important ways. First, they allowed people to pay for their CSA baskets every week or two, because a pre-payment arrangement would violate USDA rules. Second, in their USDA application to be licensed to accept EBT, they had to describe their project as a "farm stand" rather than as a CSA. Given the model they are using - members pay for the food when it is picked up - a farm stand is in fact the more accurate financial description.
Other potential snags with USDA rules (entering into contracts for food purchases, or using EBT to repay loans) were addressed in their USDA application so that they and the federal agency were clear that the "CSA" was a legitimate use of EBT.
Once their application was accepted, which Goldberg says was a fairly simple process, the farm was given a machine to swipe the CSA members' EBT cards and make the sales each week. The government then deposited the food stamp funds directly into the farm's bank account, thus making the money handling efficient and eliminating dreaded paperwork.
Finding CSA members was also painless. The farmers hung posters and brochures around town and told friends who helped spread the word. Goldberg says that acquiring shareholders was easy because so many people are interested in CSA. Most of the members are signing up again for this year's program, and the farm is already getting calls and email from other people who would like to join.
Throughout several interviews, Goldberg had one message for farmers who might consider starting a similar CSA-type program. The message is, "It's really very simple!" The only unexpected issue the couple encountered last year was the lag time between filing their application with the USDA, getting it approved, and getting set up with their EBT machine. Goldberg encourages other farmers to start the process at least two months before the beginning of the CSA. She and Campbell had an utterly positive experience with their all-EBT modified CSA. "It's so necessary and so appreciated" by the shareholders, Goldberg said. "The hardest part was figuring out who to call to get the application." We'll save you that step - here it is. Goldberg says she would be happy to talk with farmers who are considering starting this type of project, with their entire CSA, or a dedicated portion of it.
For more information on this topic or related issues you can search the thousands of archived articles on the OCA website using keywords:
Become an OCA Member! Sign up below:
diana
Feb 3 2008, 11:42 PM
Cool stuff! I also wonder if this type of modified CSA might work as an interim project for the moneyed but skeptical, until they were sold on the CSA idea.
A local college student is working to get food stamps accepted at the local farmers' market -- she is otherwise amazing, but I think she deserves sainthood or better for this one! --diana (who has found a small number of awesome 20-somethings really doing the work that needs done!)
EsperCat
Feb 5 2008, 05:40 PM
This is so awesome! Being a low-income pregnant woman myself, this really hits close to home. It's great to see people coming up with solutions. Really inspiring.
On a related note, I found a friend who will take the stuff I get from WIC, and in exchange buy some organic things. So she gets two gallons of cheapest brand milk and I get 1 organic gallon. We do the same with juice, eggs, and cereal. Thank goodness for friends
On a related note, I found a friend who will take the stuff I get from WIC, and in exchange buy some organic things. So she gets two gallons of cheapest brand milk and I get 1 organic gallon. We do the same with juice, eggs, and cereal. Thank goodness for friends
diana
Feb 5 2008, 10:09 PM
That's really sweet of your friend, but why doesn't WIC just support organic? (OK, I know why, but since they're so worried about their money, isn't it better to not poison low-income people, since 'their' money will pay for health care down the road --?) --d
EsperCat
Feb 6 2008, 05:47 PM
I whole heartedly agree with you, but when I bring it up to my caseworker she just gives me this look like "We're giving you free food, take it or leave it."
It's very frustrating also, when the only approved juice that they carry at our supermarket in the correct size is welch's grape juice. It's so sugary it makes me throw up. They used to at least carry juicy juice, but that is no longer on the approved list.
I did, however just come across this:
http://www.fns.usda.gov/wic/FMNP/FMNPfaqs.htm
Which I'm going to have to ask my caseworker about the next time I see her.
It's very frustrating also, when the only approved juice that they carry at our supermarket in the correct size is welch's grape juice. It's so sugary it makes me throw up. They used to at least carry juicy juice, but that is no longer on the approved list.
I did, however just come across this:
http://www.fns.usda.gov/wic/FMNP/FMNPfaqs.htm
Which I'm going to have to ask my caseworker about the next time I see her.
Add a Comment
Comment on this story in the OCA Forum and your comment will also be added here.
Requires a valid OCA Forum username and password.


Noticias
y campañas
de la OCA
en español




