Don't Miss Out

Subscribe to OCA's News & Alerts.

Cook Organic not the Planet Campaign

Leading NGOs Slam Greenwashing by Meat Industry, Demand Beefier Sustainability Standards

For related articles and more information, please visit OCA's CAfO's vs.Free Range page and our Myth of Natural page.

WASHINGTON, D.C. - Key consumer, animal welfare, worker, public health and environmental groups representing millions of constituents issued a scathing rejection of the Global Roundtable on Sustainable Beef's new "sustainability" principles and criteria for beef production.

Led by industry giants like McDonald's (NYSE: MCD), JBS (BZ: JBSS3) and Elanco (NYSE: LLY), the Global Roundtable is a multi-stakeholder initiative that has potential to shape how companies and producers in the U.S. and globally define sustainability in beef production.

In a letter to the Roundtable's Executive Committee, 23 groups, including Friends of the Earth, Animal Welfare Approved, Consumer Reports, Food Chain Workers Alliance, Slow Food USA, Food and Water Watch and Healthy Food Action, criticized the principles and criteria, stating:

"We-and no doubt many other organizations like us-must overwhelmingly reject the Principles and Criteria for Global Sustainable Beef. Unless the GRSB addresses the fundamental flaws outlined in our letter, the document will represent nothing more than an industry-led attempt to greenwash conventional beef production at a time when real, measurable, and verifiable change is so desperately needed."

The groups take greatest exception with GRSB's failure to address misuse of antibiotics or establish meaningful standards for workers' rights, animal welfare, or environmental performance.

"The new criteria lack specific measurable performance standards, guidelines and verification methods, making industry commitments to the Global Roundtable principles questionable at best and leaving the door wide open to greenwashing," said Kari Hamerschlag, a Senior program manager for Friends of the Earth's Food and technology program.

The McDonald's Corporation, a member of the Roundtable's Executive Committee, has already announced plans to source "sustainable" beef by 2016. Under the vague criteria, however, it's entirely unclear what this "sustainability" pledge would actually mean for the world's largest fast food chain and its suppliers.

According to the letter, the sustainability principles and criteria are "highly flawed" and fail to address key sustainability and human health issues like the routine use of non-therapeutic antibiotics in healthy animals, a key contributor to the rise of antibiotic resistance that kills more than 23,000 people in the U.S., annually.