Organic Consumers Association    News | Campaigns | GE Food | Organics | Food Locator | Events | Irradiation | Globalization | Cloning | rBGH
Mad Cow | Toxic Food | Search | Newsletter | Donate | Volunteer | About | Home | recommend site | email this page

home-Campaigns-Safeguard our students - News

McCensored: Student Punished for Criticizing McDonalds


Hank Hoffman, In These Times
July 30, 2001

Tristan Kading's first reaction was disgust. The 15-year-old Stonington
High School sophomore, a vegetarian and animal rights supporter since
elementary school, entered the cafeteria on May 22 for a mandatory assembly
and saw a McDonald's banner draped over one of the tables. A guidance
counselor had invited the fast food corporation to make a presentation on
job application and interview skills.

Kading says students had to watch a video about "how great it is to work at
McDonald's." The company's four representatives wore McDonald's hats. One
woman led the presentation while the other three reps set out fruit juice
and cookies for the kids. They were given coupons for free meals at
McDonald's for filling out job applications.

Kading volunteered to participate in a mock job interview with the
McDonald's rep after another student was sent back to his seat for making a remark about masturbation.

When the presentation leader asked Kading to talk about himself, he replied, "I hate large
corporations like McDonald's."

"That won't get you a job at McDonald's," the representative replied.

"Good, I wouldn't want to work at McDonald's," Kading added. "They falsely
advertise their french fries as vegetarian," referring to the recent controversy over the
company's failure to disclose that beef extract was used in flavoring its fries.

Calling Kading an "embarrassment to the school," a teacher sent him to the
principal's office. Kading, fearing suspension, apologized to the McDonald's representative and read an
apology over the school's intercom. "I had to do something. McDonald'sa company I hate more than a
lot of other companies -- was in our school," says Kading, a soft-spoken teen-ager who is
especially critical of the company's role in the destruction of South American rainforests to graze cattle for

For the past decade, cash-strapped school districts have succumbed to the
temptation to accept corporate programming and advertising. But critics say
these offers come at the expense of educational goals. "Schools, we hope,
are teaching critical thinking skills," says Emily Heath of the San
Francisco-based Center for Commercial Free Public Education. "Advertising
is antithetical to that. It teaches them to believe whatever is presented
to them and to take what your school endorses."

Job search skills are usually taught by teachers in the classroom,
Stonington Superintendent Michael McKee says, but many schools are trying
to "make things more relevant for students."

"It was not the belief that the student had about McDonald's" that was
being punished, McKee contends, "but rather the disruption of a
presentation of which there was educational content." McKee notes that the
job applications passed out at the assembly were for demonstration purposes
only and not collected.

McKee says that Kading's punishment sends an important message to students:
"There are forums in which our opinions or political statements are accepted and oftentimes even
sought after," such as the school paper and town meetings. "These forums become the most effective
ways to get our beliefs known."

Stonington High School senior Billy Ware dismisses this idea: "It's not
like he got up there cursing. He made an educated remark about a current event." The issue of beef flavoring
in McDonald's fries, Ware notes, "is something that's in the court system."

"The assembly was the best time for him to say something," adds James
Morren, a junior at Stonington. He says the controversy might cause a lot of students who
hadn't heard of animal rights to become interested.

Contrary to McKee, these students believe it was Kading's politics that got
him into trouble. They note that he was dealt with more harshly than the student who was just sent back
to his seat for making the lewd remark.

Morren and Ware agree that if corporations are allowed in schools, then
alternate voices should also be represented, conscientious objectors to balance Army recruiters, PETA
activists to respond to McDonald's. "It was blatant self-advertising," Ware says of the assembly.
"I don't support McDonald's in any way. But when they came into the school, I had to listen
to them. The worst was when they handed out the coupons, like one french fry to each kid."

News | GE Food | Organics | Food Locator | Events | Irradiation | Globalization | Cloning | rBGH
Mad Cow | Toxic Food | About Us | Newsletter | Donate | Join Us | Keyword Search | Home - tell a friend
Campaigns : Starbucks : Safeguard our Students : Monsanto Watch
Please support our work, send a tax-deductible donation to OCA

to BioDemocracy News
(published every 6 weeks) previous issues

Organic Consumers Association
6101 Cliff Estate Rd., Little Marais, MN 55614
Activist or Media Inquiries: (218) 226-4164,  Fax: (218) 226-4157